Aaronovitch was born to a Camden-dwelling Jewish communist and was a member of the Manchester team in the TV programme University Challenge who made complete arses of themselves by answering all questions with "Trotsky", "Lenin", "Karl Marx" and "Che Guevara"; but nobody chooses their parents, and boys will be boys. Since leaving the Guardian he has attracted sufficient bitchiness from his erstwhile comrades to suggest he has turned his back on the more ridiculous extremes of British leftism.
However, he appears unable to emancipate himself entirely from his Marxist indoctrination, so he still looks to poverty as the explanation for social pathology. Something else he cannot emancipate himself from may explain why he doesn't mention the revolting custom of female genital mutilation. Thus, as far as he is concerned the disgusting acts perpetrated against women in some societies is worse than a crime:
Far more than that, the oppression - oppression is what it is [and who the hell, apart from some of his old Guardian comrades, questions it?] - of women holds back social and economic development in societies that practise legal misogyny, making them poorer and more violent. . . . And where there are more young men than young women, as a result of polygamy and early death [he does mention female infanticide earlier], there I bet there is also more violence, more psycho-sexual dysfunction, more substitution of the bomb for the girlfriend. And we all get it in the neck.Ah, so we should be concerned about the brutalisation of women not because it is a barbaric offense against humanity, but because the primitive cultures that permit it will also produce young men who will express their sexual frustration by blowing themselves up, possibly in our vicinity?
How morally abject is that? But in addition there is no link whatever between poverty and Islamist suicide bombing. Further, our suicide bombers have been home-grown in a society where sexual frustration can only be the product of choice. Even a strangulated Marxhorroid ought to be able to see that.
Hampstead Jewish Communist?
ReplyDeleteIf you have a tagline like cutting the crap you might want to try a bit harder to get your facts right.
Sam Aaronovitch was from the East End, he was an atheist but the communist bit was correct. One out of three aint bad.
David went to Gospel Oak primary school, which backs on to Hampstead Heath (OK - the family could have been living in Camden), and excuse me all to hell if I assumed Aaronovitch was a Jewish name.
ReplyDeleteWell you have to be really hard-up for oxymorons if you think 'Jewish atheist' is one any more than 'Jewish Communist.' And after all, isn't the greatest bourgeois Jewish atheist Communist of them all in permanent residence in Highgate Cemetry?
ReplyDelete